Division I:
First Team All-Region
| Player Name | School | Position | Year |
| Ales Kohoutek | Indian Hills | D | Fr. |
| Alex Rodriguez | Indian Hills | F | Fr. |
| Daniel Mulero | Indian Hills | F | Fr. |
| Fernando Pirri | Indian Hills | F | Fr. |
| Gustavo Marques | Indian Hills | F | So. |
| Harvey Sellers | Indian Hills | GK | Fr. |
| Lucas Bauer | Indian Hills | F | Fr. |
| Jaehyuk Moon | Iowa Western | D | So. |
| Ryusei Shimonishi | Iowa Western | D | So. |
| Stefan Bilinac | Iowa Western | M | So. |
| Timothy Mason | Iowa Western | M | So. |
Player of the Year: Timothy Mason, Iowa Western
Coach of the Year: Felix Vu, Indian Hills
Division II:
First Team All-Region:
| Name | School | Position | Year |
| Anders Lauridsen | Hawkeye | F | Fr. |
| Edgar Salazar Buenano | Iowa Central | CAM | Fr. |
| Emilio Cazares | Iowa Lakes | F | Fr. |
| Eugenio Perez | Iowa Lakes | D/M | So. |
| Keiji Sugiura | Iowa Lakes | M | Fr. |
| Haruya Higuchi | Marshalltown | F | Fr. |
| Yuki Fujita | Marshalltown | F | So. |
| Edouard Nys | Northeast | M | Fr. |
| Lewis Rourke | Northeast | F | Fr. |
| Luca Baltzer | Northeast | M | So. |
| Mathias Kristoffersen | Northeast | GK | Fr. |
| Cristobal Gutierrez | Southeastern | M | So. |
| Jordi Masegosa | Southeastern | M | Fr. |
| Matias Garcia Castilla | Western Iowa Tech | D | Fr. |
Second Team All-Region:
| Name | School | Position | Year |
| Magnus Jensen | Hawkeye | D | So. |
| Matias Vila | Iowa Central | RB | So. |
| Gabriel Miranda | Iowa Lakes | D/M/F | Fr. |
| Matheus Loreto | Iowa Lakes | D | So. |
| Philmour Virgo | Iowa Lakes | M/F | So. |
| Ivan Felipe Isaacs | Marshalltown | M/F | So. |
| Gabriel Uemura | Marshalltown | D | So. |
| Hugo Doran | NIACC | F | So. |
| Luca Rosen | Northeast | F | Fr. |
| Lucas Van Den Berg | Northeast | D | Fr. |
| Sergio Aznar | Northeast | D | So. |
| Teun van der Donk | Northeast | D | So. |
| Juan Anguiano | Scott | CM | So. |
| Diego Lozano | Southeastern | F | Fr. |
| Diego Regueira | Southeastern | F | So. |
| Sebastian Gonzalez | Southeastern | D | So. |
| Victor Goscinski | Western Iowa Tech | GK | So. |
Honorable Mention All-Region:
| Name | School | Position | Year |
| Agustin Sisti | Hawkeye | D | Fr. |
| Owen Johnson | Hawkeye | GK | So. |
| Caden Ruff | Iowa Central | CDM | So. |
| Samuel Castro Orozco | Iowa Central | CDM | So. |
| Darian Bradshaw | Iowa Lakes | M | So. |
| Lucas Catosso | Iowa Lakes | D/F | So. |
| Juan Cortez | Marshalltown | M | Fr. |
| Kai Yoshida | Marshalltown | D | Fr. |
| Giorgio Dalzini | NIACC | D | Fr. |
| Aleksander Pedersen | Northeast | M | Fr. |
| Tom Hennah | Northeast | D | So. |
| Victor Hidalgo | Northeast | M | Fr. |
| Cole Fender | Scott | CB | Fr. |
| Jose Luis Alvares | Southeastern | D | Fr. |
| Juan Hernandez | Southeastern | D | So. |
| Gabriel Avellan | Western Iowa Tech | M/F | Fr. |
| Ryder Delport | Western Iowa Tech | M/D | Fr. |
Player of the Year: Edouard Nys, Northeast
Coach of the Year: Adam Potter, Northeast
2023 All-Tournament Team
| 2023 Division II Men's Soccer All-Tournament | |||
| Name | School | Position | Year |
| Emilio Cazares | Iowa Lakes | F | Fr. |
| Engenio Perez | Iowa Lakes | D / M | So. |
| Kenji Sugiura | Iowa Lakes | M | Fr. |
| Philmour Virgo | Iowa Lakes | M / F | So. |
| Kai Yoshida | Marshalltown | D | Fr. |
| Kenshin Akimoto | Marshalltown | F | Fr. |
| Edouard Nys (OFF) | Northeast | F | Fr. |
| Lewis Rourke (MVP) | Northeast | F | Fr. |
| Luca Baltzer | Northeast | M | So. |
| Mathias Kristoffersen (GK) | Northeast | G | Fr. |
| Sergio Aznar (DEF) | Northeast | D | So. |
| Victor Hidalgo | Northeast | M | Fr. |