1st Team All-Region
| Position | Name | Class | School |
| RB | CJ Francis | SO | Ellsworth |
| C | Jeff Meyer | FR | Ellsworth |
| RB | Joe Morris | SO | Ellsworth |
| TE | Luke Brocka | SO | Ellsworth |
| CB | Theo Jones | SO | Ellsworth |
| OL | Adam Dutcher | SO | Iowa Central |
| LB | Amari Spievey | FR | Iowa Central |
| LB | Anthony Pritchard | FR | Iowa Central |
| RB | Jake Peterson | SO | Iowa Central |
| DL | Josh Johnson | SO | Iowa Central |
| OL | Mike Manternach | SO | Iowa Central |
| CB | Quentin Scott | SO | Iowa Central |
| WR | Brad Theilen | SO | NIACC |
| P | Jacob Grobe | FR | NIACC |
| OL | Kyle Staudt | SO | NIACC |
| QB | Lorenzo Brown | SO | NIACC |
| WR | Marques Parker | SO | NIACC |
| DE | Mike Daniels | SO | NIACC |
| DT | Reggie St. Pierre | SO | NIACC |
| K | Ryan McMahon | FR | NIACC |
| DE | Jarrett Crittenton | SO | North Dakota |
| WR | Jason Carlson | FR | North Dakota |
| OLB | Jay Johnson | FR | North Dakota |
| OL | Ricky Henry | SO | North Dakota |
All-Region Honorable Mention
| Position | Name | Class | School |
| LB | Jeremy Crowder | SO | Ellsworth |
| QB | Jessie Bundrage | SO | Ellsworth |
| LB | Joe Forgy | FR | Ellsworth |
| LB | Kori Moore | FR | Ellsworth |
| CB | Terrell Tillman | SO | Ellsworth |
| LB | Antwan Pratt | FR | NIACC |
| TE | Cale Johnston | SO | NIACC |
| DB | DJ Pratt | FR | NIACC |
| LB | Gerard Oxendine | FR | NIACC |
| WR | Jameel Williams | SO | NIACC |
| WR | Joe Audlehelm | FR | NIACC |
| DB | Josh Berry | FR | NIACC |
| DE | Kevin Jacque | SO | NIACC |
| RB | Kevis Streeter | FR | NIACC |
| DB | Laquentin Black | FR | NIACC |
| LB | Luke Dolan | SO | NIACC |
| TE | Ryan Luedtke | SO | NIACC |
| RB | Travis Etchl | FR | NIACC |
| G | Wes Yarbough | SO | NIACC |
| QB | Derek Stripling | SO | North Dakota |
| FS | James Allison | SO | North Dakota |
| SS | Jerrel McGee | FR | North Dakota |
| T | Kyle Richardson | SO | North Dakota |
| RB | Kyle Wetzel | FR | North Dakota |
| WR | Nick Pederson | FR | North Dakota |
| OLB | Rodney Harris | SO | North Dakota |
| DB | Victor Reynolds | FR | North Dakota |
| OLB | Will Kassulker | SO | North Dakota |